Better Health: Smart Health Commentary Better Health (TM): smart health commentary

Article Comments (1)

Bartering For Medical Care: A Chicken For A Checkup?

In the annals of “Things You Probably Wish You Hadn’t Said,” Sue Lowden, the Republican candidate to replace Nevada Senator Harry Reid, suggested last week that bartering for medical care was a workable substitute for the Affordable Care Act, which she is campaigning to repeal.

Surprisingly, after being called out and roundly mocked for the suggestion, she doubled down on the idea:

“You know, before we all started having healthcare, in the olden days, our grandparents, they would bring a chicken to the doctor. They would say, ‘I’ll paint your house.’”

I know that it’s hardly fair to pile on someone running for office for a bit of stump-speech dumbassery, but it just needs to be said. As much as I enjoy a nice chicken sandwich from time to time, barter is not a feasible mode of payment for services anymore. A doctor can’t pay his staff, his rent, or his malpractice insurance in chickens. 

A related suggestion was the idea of patients negotiating the price for services directly with their doctors. This also fails the giggle test on a number of levels. 

First of all, that is one of the advantages of belonging to an insurance program — they do the negotiating for you, and because of their size they command much deeper discounts than any individual ever could. This assumes that a doctor even cares to discuss price with an individual patient. I never do this in the ER, not only because of the circumstances, but because I honestly don’t know in advance exactly which of the thousands of codes (and prices) a given patient interaction will result in. Moreover, without the protection of insurance, the likelihood that any private individual will be able to afford the cost of an ER visit — let alone a surgery or hospitalization – is essentially nil.

It’s depressing to realize that there’s a substantial likelihood that this dimwit will be the next senator from Nevada.

Update: Also, it was noted that her history includes a malicious indifference to the healthcare needs of those less fortunate than herself: When Sue Lowden headed a Santa Fe hotel and casino, management forced a group of workers to shift to part-time status and sign away their healthcare coverage, said a judge who ruled that the company violated fair labor practices. 

Nice. That’s a real charmer you’re sending to the senate, Nevada.

*This blog post was originally published at Movin' Meat*


You may also like these posts

Read comments »


One Response to “Bartering For Medical Care: A Chicken For A Checkup?”

  1. Matthew Bowdish MD says:

    I am not sure this dimwit will be any worse than the current one in that seat.

    But I have to take issue with you on your belief that empowering patients to become better medical consumers will not drive down health care costs. Real world data doesn’t seem to support that argument.

    Now, EDs are not exactly the place where you would expect market forces to be beneficial, nor is OR, which is why I think your examples are somewhat irrelevant. We definitely should have insurance for such catastrophic events as ED/OR visits. That’s really what ‘insurance’ is…a bet on the chance that one might have a heart attack, or cancer, or appendicitis.

    However, I would argue that routine primary care activities could use a health dose of market forces and more consumer skepticism. For example, I am an allergist. As such, I know that I would like to offer a number of services that my patients that might give them (and me) more info on their condition. But I am under no illusion that most of what I offer is absolutely medically-necessary. Why check five tree pollen skin tests when I can do one tree mix test? Yes, the added info is helpful, but is it worth the cost? I wrestle with these kind of decisions everyday. I also find that my patients often will say ‘more is better,’ especially if the insurance company is paying for it. If they paid for it, they would be more discerning on what really important to them.

    Furthermore, your argument that insurance companies are advocates FOR patients doesn’t really hold. They are, more often than not, acting at limiting access to care rather than effectively or compassionately negotiating for patients, most of whom don’t pay for their insurance but get it through the real payers….their employers. Needless to say, all of these third parties lead to a rather skewed interaction where the patient is often left out of the loop.

    If a patient has say, a consumer-driven health care plan (CDH) that operates both as true insurance (covering catastrophic issues) and allows the patients to control and guide his/her own routine health care dollars, then costs can be driven down.

    For example, a study released last year by the American Academy of Actuaries proved as much.

    http://www.marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2009/08/consumer-drive-health-care-plans.html

    The AAA showed CDHs decrease costs an average of 12-21% over traditional insurance plans. Introducing true market pressure into an industry where doctors like yourself self-admittedly don’t even understand the true costs of their work can only help save patients money.

    But you may retort that patients would then neglect primary care with such market pressures. Interestingly, that’s not the case. The same study found that when patients took a greater role in their health care decision making, and were able to affect its cost, they underwent ‘needed’ screening. Furthermore, the care they received also tended to conform better to evidence-based standards than did the care they received under traditional insurance. When push comes to shove, patients learn what is important and extract the maximal amount of value in the patient-physician interaction.

    Now on to the point that started me reading your article-bartering. I have on occasion taken bartered items from my patients in exchange for my services. That’s easier to do as a physician working in a private practice rather then your experience as, essentially, an employee of a hospital emergency department.

    While one cannot completely run a business through bartering alone, in some circumstances it has allowed my patients to get care they need while I have been able to be reimbursed for my labor. Accordingly, I wouldn’t mock such interactions as they really connect me and my patients in relationships that I have found much more meaningful that waiting for a check from Aetna.

Return to article »

Latest Interviews

Caring For Winter Olympians In Sochi: An Interview With Team USA’s Chief Medical Officer Dr. Gloria Beim

I am a huge fan of the winter Olympics partly because I grew up in Canada where most kids can ski and skate before they can run and partly because I used to participate in Downhill ski racing. Now that I m a rehab physician with a reconstructed knee I…

Read more »

How Do Hospital Executives Feel About Locum Tenens Agencies And Traveling Physicians?

I recently wrote about my experiences as a traveling physician and how to navigate locum tenens work. Today I want to talk about the client in this case hospital side of the equation. I ve had the chance to speak with several executives some were physicians themselves about the overall…

Read more »

See all interviews »

Latest Cartoon

See all cartoons »

Latest Book Reviews

The Spirit Of The Place: Samuel Shem’s New Book May Depress You

When I was in medical school I read Samuel Shem s House Of God as a right of passage. At the time I found it to be a cynical yet eerily accurate portrayal of the underbelly of academic medicine. I gained comfort from its gallows humor and it made me…

Read more »

Eat To Save Your Life: Another Half-True Diet Book

I am hesitant to review diet books because they are so often a tangled mess of fact and fiction. Teasing out their truth from falsehood is about as exhausting as delousing a long-haired elementary school student. However after being approached by the authors’ PR agency with the promise of a…

Read more »

Unaccountable: A Book About The Underbelly Of Hospital Care

I met Dr. Marty Makary over lunch at Founding Farmers restaurant in DC about three years ago. We had an animated conversation about hospital safety the potential contribution of checklists to reducing medical errors and his upcoming book about the need for more transparency in the healthcare system. Marty was…

Read more »

See all book reviews »