Better Health: Smart Health Commentary Better Health (TM): smart health commentary

Article Comments (3)

Is It A Crime To Help Illegal Immigrants Get Healthcare?

According to some state legislators, the answer is yes. Lawmakers in South Carolina are pushing legislation that would “make it illegal to transport immigrants anywhere, including a hospital” reports the New York Times. Fox News Phoenix reports that in Arizona, a bill has been introduced to “require hospitals, when admitting nonemergency cases, to confirm that a person seeking care is a U.S. citizen or in the country legally. In emergency cases where the patient isn’t here legally, the hospital would be required to call immigration authorities after the treatment is done. Hospitals in non-emergency situations would also be required to contact federal immigration authorities, but they would have more apparent discretion about whether to treat illegal immigrants.”

Such ill-advised efforts by states to criminalize health care for undocumented persons has led the American College of Physicians, the nation’s second largest physician organization, to speak out against “Any law that might require physicians to share confidential information, such as citizenship status to the authorities, that was gained through the patient–physician relationship conflicts with the ethical and professional duties of physicians.” ACP made this statement in a new position paper on immigrants’ access to health care released yesterday at its annual scientific meeting in San Diego, California.

Moreover, ACP argues that, “Access to health care for immigrants is a national issue and needs to be addressed with a national policy. Individual state laws will not be adequate to address this national problem and will result in a patchwork solution.” A national policy on immigrants’ access to health care should include the following elements, says ACP:

- Taxpayers should not be required to subsidize health insurance coverage for persons who are not legal residents of the United States and people should not be prevented from paying out-of-pocket for health insurance based on immigration status.

- The same access to health coverage and government-subsidized health care for U.S.-born children of parents who lack legal residency should be the same as any other U.S. citizen.

- Acknowledgement of the public health risks associated with undocumented persons not receiving medical care because of concerns about criminal or civil prosecution or deportation.

- Immigration policy should include increased access to comprehensive primary and preventive care, and vaccinations and screening for prevalent infectious diseases. This will make better use of public health dollars by improving the health status of this population and alleviating the need for costly emergency care.

- Federal government support for safety-net health care facilities and offsets for costs of uncompensated care provided by these facilities.

- Acknowledgment that physicians and other health care professionals have an ethical and professional obligation to care for the sick. Immigration policy should not interfere with the ethical obligation to provide care for all.

- Policies that do not foster discrimination against a class or category of patients in the provision of health care.

ACP concluded with a “call to action” for a national policy that recognizes the need for the country to control whom it admits within its borders and to differentiate its treatment of those who comply with the law in establishing legal residency from those who do not, while recognizing that hospitals and physicians have an ethical obligation to provide care for residents lacking legal documentation.

Some readers of this blog might question why ACP is wading into the complex, controversial, and polarizing debate over immigrants’ access to health care. (ACP’s paper addresses only questions relating to immigrants’ access to health care, not broader immigration policy.) But in my opinion, ACP should be praised for confronting an issue that affects health care for tens of millions of persons in the United States, documented and undocumented alike. As ACP President Fred Ralston, MD, MACP remarked at yesterday’s press event, “Access to health care for immigrants is crucial to the overall population of the U.S. We all have a vested interest in ensuring that all residents have access to necessary care.”

If physicians don’t speak up for their patients, even those who lack legal residency, who will? Not federal and state politicians, that’s for sure.

Today’s question: What is your reaction to ACP’s call for a national policy on access to care for immigrants that is in accord with physicians’ ethical obligation to care for the sick?

*This blog post was originally published at The ACP Advocate Blog by Bob Doherty*


You may also like these posts

Read comments »


3 Responses to “Is It A Crime To Help Illegal Immigrants Get Healthcare?”

  1. I agree that ACP should be praised for what passes these days as a brave stand. We need to stop demonizing and start dealing with these issues with a more rational, comprehensive, national approach.

  2. Michael Wong says:

    Interesting question. The practical implications are that before anyone administers medical care to a patient, they’d have to ask whether that patient is an illegal immigrant. So, that if someone is lying bleeding in the street, we’d have to ask “are you an illegal immigrant?” If the answer is no or we were not satisfied, then we’d have to walk on!? Or, if one of these legislators is unconscious and it was not clear what they were an illegal immigrant, they’d be denied care. Yes, indeed, an interesting question!

  3. israel martinez says:

    I feel sad about goverment decicions in almost every aspect about illigal inmmigrants, i can feel the fear and the impotence of illigal inmmigrants, i can see the sorrow of my friends and family when they are trying to get opportunities, sometimes they have to fight harder to get food to their homes, to survive in this f… county of freedom, now i cant do anything to help them?, but say what i feel, things must change, illigals are persons no criminals!

Return to article »

Latest Interviews

IDEA Labs: Medical Students Take The Lead In Healthcare Innovation

It’s no secret that doctors are disappointed with the way that the U.S. healthcare system is evolving. Most feel helpless about improving their work conditions or solving technical problems in patient care. Fortunately one young medical student was undeterred by the mountain of disappointment carried by his senior clinician mentors…

Read more »

How To Be A Successful Patient: Young Doctors Offer Some Advice

I am proud to be a part of the American Resident Project an initiative that promotes the writing of medical students residents and new physicians as they explore ideas for transforming American health care delivery. I recently had the opportunity to interview three of the writing fellows about how to…

Read more »

See all interviews »

Latest Cartoon

See all cartoons »

Latest Book Reviews

Book Review: Is Empathy Learned By Faking It Till It’s Real?

I m often asked to do book reviews on my blog and I rarely agree to them. This is because it takes me a long time to read a book and then if I don t enjoy it I figure the author would rather me remain silent than publish my…

Read more »

The Spirit Of The Place: Samuel Shem’s New Book May Depress You

When I was in medical school I read Samuel Shem s House Of God as a right of passage. At the time I found it to be a cynical yet eerily accurate portrayal of the underbelly of academic medicine. I gained comfort from its gallows humor and it made me…

Read more »

Eat To Save Your Life: Another Half-True Diet Book

I am hesitant to review diet books because they are so often a tangled mess of fact and fiction. Teasing out their truth from falsehood is about as exhausting as delousing a long-haired elementary school student. However after being approached by the authors’ PR agency with the promise of a…

Read more »

See all book reviews »