Better Health: Smart Health Commentary Better Health (TM): smart health commentary

Article Comments

Physicians And Open Source Health Advice

Last week someone posted on Twitter that they had swallowed a plastic toothpick. What to do? So they turned to the hive for help. “What should I do?” I thought as I read my Twitter feed. I was paralyzed in a way. I wanted to share my experience with hundreds of patients had swallowed pins, toothpicks and other pointy things. I specialize in just this sort of thing. But short of a random comment about gastric emptying, I kept to myself. Why? Because once I lend a hand I’m all in.

The simple offer of patient-specific advice constitutes a relationship in the eyes of the law. Once involved, I potentially share responsibility in whatever happens to someone. Crazy but true. It’s just a matter of time before slip-and-fall lawyers hold physicians accountable for helping out in the social sphere.

Doctors aren’t the only ones wearing targets.

In the virtual land grab to get a piece of the chronically ill we’ve witnessed the growth of a cottage industry composed of alternative providers. I suspect that well-insured health sites providing safe harbor for mavens, disease experts, gurus, advisors and other self-anointed authorities will at some point feel the sting of the trial bar.

Attorneys and gurus aside, health professionals need to worry about doing the very best for those looking for help.

Here’s a thought: Unless a practitioner has the critical details of someone’s current complaint, a complete history, record of medications/allergies, a medium by which crystal-clear communication can be exchanged and a reproducible record where it can all be recorded, it’s risky and potentially irresponsible to offer passing medical advice.

That’s the kind of advocacy you won’t hear much about.

The heady exuberance of open source medical advice will play itself out. The market’s never wrong. Good, responsible care, however, will never go out of style.

And one last thing: What if you know I read about the toothpick and failed to lend a hand? Let’s not go there…

*This blog post was originally published at 33 Charts*


You may also like these posts

Read comments »


Return to article »

Leave a Reply

Latest Interviews

Health Tips For Back-To-School

I was lucky enough to be asked by one of the local TV stations to talk about some back-to-school issues when it comes to health. I don t know about where you re at but most of the local schools around here started yesterday August rd Keeping up-to-date on immunizations…

Read more »

“Medical Self-Care” And The Doc Tom Interview

Next in our series of posts about our founder Doc Tom. Previous time capsules and Come ye economics buffs and algebra fans Get out your pencils and solve for x n and XX Whatever else the year XX is remembered for it will without a doubt go down in history…

Read more »

See all interviews »

Latest Cartoon

cardiaccath

Here’s a cartoon I created a few years back. Enjoy!

- Dr. Val

*This blog post was originally published at Science-Based Medicine*

See all cartoons »

Latest Book Reviews

A Biomedical Look At Spaceflight

Book review by Dan Buckland Dan Buckland is an editor at Medgadget and an MD PhD student at Harvard Med MIT whose thesis deals with diagnosing back injury in spaceflight using ultrasound. Mary Roach author of previous entertaining books Bonk a history of sex research and Stiff a history of…

Read more »

UTI and “Eat, Pray, Love”

I really didn t expect to like Eat Pray Love. In fact since its publication in I’d been avoiding it like the plague. Typical new-agey Oprah-y girly-book I thought. Nothing in it to speak to me. Then I saw the trailer for the movie and I was hooked probably because…

Read more »

Will Science Succeed With An Anti-Aging Revolution?

Wouldn’t it be great if we could find a way to prolong our lives and to keep us healthy right up to the end Ponce de León never found that Fountain of Youth but science is still looking. What are the chances science will succeed How’s it doing so far…

Read more »

See all book reviews »